



I loved the element of Tamsin beginning to see flashes of color in Wren. Wren is frustrated to find herself falling for someone who a) is incapable of loving her back, b) is going to take her love for her father from her as soon as Tamsin completes her end of the deal, and c) is kind of a jerk to her. While there is a high fantasy plot here, including magical duels, family secrets, and a world in the balance, it becomes obvious that the heart of this story is the romance between Wren and Tamsin. I only wish we got a little more of their travel Within (where there’s walking cottages and all kinds of weird stuff), but I recognize that probably wouldn’t fit the pacing. I really enjoy “quest” stories that involve a fantasy travel journey, and I loved seeing Tamsin and Wren clash as they tried to get through it together. Together, they have to journey to Within (aka the Witchlands) to begin their hunt for the witch responsible for the dark magic that is causing havoc–the same Within that cursed and banished Tamsin 5 years earlier. In the present day, neither of them thinks they are worthy of happiness. Wren has tried to be the “good girl” her whole life, always making herself small Tamsin was the star student, a rule follower. They both have spent their lives living it for others, only to be punished for it. Tamsin has a martyr complex Wren is self-sacrificial to a fault. They seem like opposites–but in reality, they have most of the same motivations. Wren is bubbly, naïve, and distractible she sees magic everywhere. Tamsin is jaded, haunted by her past, and literally incapable of love or positive emotion. Tamsin and Wren have a perfect grouchy one/sunshine one dynamic. This is a high fantasy story with big, world-ending stakes–but more importantly, it’s a slow burn sapphic romance. When a magical plague ravages the queendom (including Wren’s father), they team up to try to stop it. After her mother died, she’s been stuck taking care of her sickly father, though what she really wants to do is go to the Witchlands and nurture her power. She would be an incredible book for witches, but she’s kept herself hidden–her brother was killed because of the actions of a witch, and her family fears magic. Wren is a source: someone made of magic, but who can’t use it herself. When the townspeople fall ill or are in need of big magic, they come to her and offer up their love for their children or spouse in exchange, and she carefully rations that small store of emotion. Without love, she can’t see colors, taste food, or feel warmth. Worse, she was cursed, and now she can’t feel love unless she takes it from others. Tamsin is a 17-year-old witch who was banished from her community of witches when she was 12, for committing the worse of magical crimes.
